Bread Evangelizing

fresh baked bread

I was on my way to the Whole Wallet, errr, Foods the other day to stock up on ingredients for another baking day, when I ran into one of the meetup mamas. As soon as I said “baking day” she got a gleam in her eye and said, “Do you bake your own bread?” When I said yes, she practically jumped up and down, saying, “Will you teach me? Maybe we could do a meetup..?” So that’s the plan, for this next Monday. Six mamas will come over with kiddos in tow and hopefully things will be un-chaotic enough that they can actually learn a thing or two.

I love the idea, anyway. Mamas getting together and pooling knowledge and skills. My dream is that it will work beautifully and turn into a regular thing. I feel that I have a fair number of skills to share, and I would love the opportunity to learn some new ones.

Bread is a great place to start. I’m somewhat of an evangelist when it comes to homemade bread. Here’s the invite I sent out for the group:

“Learn to Make Your Own Wholesome Homemade Bread!

-It’s easy, less than 30 minutes of work for 2 loaves of bread. No fancy equipment.
-It’s cheap! Make delicious, FRESH whole wheat bread for about $1/loaf!
-It’s healthy. Not so much sugar and sodium as store bought, and no preservatives!
-Entice your husband, wife, or other significant back into the honeymoon phase with the smell of baking bread (or woo random strangers off the street!)
-It’s de-fabu-licious!

Finally, when the kiddos just want bread and butter for dinner, you won’t feel quite so guilty…”

If you want to join the fun, here’s my first bread recipe, which made me a convert so long ago. I still know it by heart, even though I haven’t used it in years. This is an ultra basic no-frills technique that bread purist will scoff at, but it’s easy! and delicious!  Especially good to give a beginner the success they need to inspire further bread pursuits! After you’ve gotten more comfortable with the whole process you can start fiddling with it. I’ll make a “fiddling with it” post someday soon.

Calamity Jane’s No-Nonsense Everyday Whole Wheat Bread

This recipe makes 2 loaves.

  • 3 cups whole wheat flour
  • 3 cups white flour (preferably bread flour, but all-purpose will work fine)
  • 3 T gluten flour (this is optional, I only recently started adding gluten flour. It makes your bread more cohesive and chewy)
  • 2 Tablespoons yeast
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • 1/4 cup honey
  • 1/2 stick butter, melted (you can use oil, works fine, and you don’t have to dirty an extra dish for melting…)
  • 2 1/2 cups warm not hot! water

Measure all the dry ingredients into a big bowl, stir it up good, then measure the wet stuff right onto the top. With a stout wooden spoon, stir it up until it becomes too hard to stir, then dump the lot out onto a floured countertop. Let the kids go feral and the phone ring off the hook while you get yer hands in there and work all that messy looking stuff into a nice cohesive dough, adding more flour as necessary to make it workable and keep the sticking to a minimum. Add just a little at a time to avoid adding too much, you want the dough soft (this is actually one of the only tricky parts, too stiff a dough will make a thick hard loaf, but since different flours in different climates absorb different amounts of water, I can’t tell you exactly how much flour you’ll need. Probably at least another cup, maybe 2, possibly more. Just keep chanting ‘soft dough, soft dough’ and bare in mind that it will be annoyingly sticky, that’s normal, wheat dough is always sticky.)

Ideally you would knead the dough for ten minutes, but you’ll be tired after five, and really, five is fine. Even three will work. Return the dough to the bowl, cover with plastic, and let rise for about an hour. Checking whether dough is fully risen is the other tricky part, and another thing I can’t give you any exact directions for because it will take dramatically longer or shorter depending on how warm it is, how wet your dough was, etc. The idea is to poke your finger in to it, if it springs back it’s not ready. When it’s ready, the dough will just hold the indented shape of your finger. The first few times, check your dough frequently so you can see what it looks like when it’s not done, half done, 3/4 done, and done. If you wait too long after it’s done, it will fall. Fortunately, this first rising is not important to get perfect, it’s your practice round.

Anyway, whenever you’ve determined it’s done rising, dump it out onto your counter again, cut it into two pieces, and with each piece press into a rough rectangle and roll tightly into a log, the length of your bread pan. It would have been handy to grease up your bread pans before you got your hands doughy. Set the logs into those greased pans, cover with plastic and let rise again.

They won’t take as long to rise the second time, maybe 40 minutes. Keep checking them. After about 20 minutes you’ll want to start your oven at 350 so it’s good and hot by the time the bread’s risen.

Bake for about 50 minutes, till the top is nicely browned and the loaf sounds hollow when you thump on the bottom.

Cool on a wire rack for at least 15 minutes before you try cutting into it. Enjoy piping hot with organic butter!

*** Post Script: When we made this recipe for the meetup it was great, but I’m used to a much wheatier loaf, and found it kind of boring. Starting with half and half white to wheat is good to get your bearings, I really recommend it. Then, if you like denser, darker, wheatier bread start using 1 cup more of wheat flour (and 1 cup less white) each time till you arrive at your perfect loaf. I made 100% whole wheat for years. Lately I’ve been doing about 80% wheat.

Also, I ought to mention that trying to teach/learn anything with 5 toddlers squealing and writhing at our feet was fairly hopeless. I like to think they at least left with a new motivation….

14 thoughts on “Bread Evangelizing

  1. Thanks for the easiest bread recipe I’ve ever used. I feel like my dream of baking all the fam’s bread this winter could become a reality. I just pulled out a batch of bread , one loaf of which I rolled up with cinnamon and raisins. YUM! Can’t wait till the kids get home from school so I get win some super mom points!

    1. Oh, I’m sosooo glad you took the time to tell me this! Sometimes blogging is like shouting into a black hole, it’s always good to find out anyone’s even listening, let alone following recipes! Let alone being happy with them!

  2. I was the lucky recipient of one of Heather’s loaves of cinnamon raisin bread! Fantastic bread! I can’t wait to try this recipe this weekend.

  3. This bread is sooo good! Heather passed the recipe along to me and my family is enjoying it. I’ve been baking bread on & off for years, but never knew how to test when the bread was done rising. All the recipes ever say is, “let rise an hour or until double in size” – well, that poking test is right on. Bread seems to rise a heck of a lot faster in my house, so now I get nice fluffy loaves with a great sponge. Thanks for that tip. I also found it interesting that you don’t brush the bread with anything before baking. It comes out just fine with a great crust. I’d be interested in more whole wheat recipes or any bread bible books you can recommend.

    Thanks! How’s life down south?


  4. I will re-enter the world of bread baking when the season returns to cool. Somehow turning on an oven now annoys me. I’d like the master bread backing on my backyard barbeque – Imagine it would work. Have you every tried it?

    1. yup. i got a big ‘que off craigslist partly for that purpose. it works. i made some fantastic baguettes, and nothing could be better for flatbreads (just throw ’em right on the grill, a minute each side, i blogged about this last summer) i experimented a lot with the grill, but in the end decided it uses so much more gas than an indoor oven, because it is just not built to keep heat in whatsoever, that it just wasn’t worth it. i’ll write more about my hot weather bread baking ideas and experiments in the upcoming “techniques” post.

    1. absolutely! just use brown sugar or brown rice syrup or whatever your prefferred sweetener is. honey does especially help the bread to stay moist longer because of it’s high fructose content, but brown sugar will do this too because of the molasses.

  5. Girl you are seriously the homemade bread diva. I love how you laid out this post, it was super helpful and descriptive. I threw that loaf together like a pro. I found this one via your post about making your own sprouted grain bread. I read all your articles on bread and am taking your advice starting with this recipe. Actually, it is cooling on my counter top this very moment…and my house smells divine! No more store bought bread for me, and your blog is going in my RSS!

  6. I used to bake bread for my uncle all the time when I was a teen. This is making me want to do it again. The only problem is my bread never turns out quite so pretty :)

  7. Oh and by the way, I just noticed “Radical Homemakers” on your blog roll. I just read it and I’m pretty sure it changed my flippin’ life! Hence, the reason I went looking for homemade bread recipes on Google!

  8. So this has been my go-to recipe since I found it. Love it. But lately, anytime I use more wheat flour than AP or bread flour, it doesn’t rise. What gives? I used to make it half and half but I like the wheat taste and we are trying to move away from white flour so I’ve tried using 4 cups wheat and 2 cups AP or bread flour and every time I use more than half wheat, it turns out like a brick. I knead the same, rise times are the same, I’ve used yeast purchased at different times/different stores. I usually use butter and honey and today I tried it with brown sugar and oil just for kicks to see it if helped but it didn’t. I’m going crazy with brick bread over here. Help!

    1. Hi Tonia, so glad this recipe has become a favorite.
      Brick bread is the worst. I’m guessing if you use white bread flour instead of all-purpose the problem will be solved. Wheat flour has less gluten than white, so the extra gluten in bread flour makes up for that. Gluten is the glue that holds the bubbles in, which is what allows your bread to rise up from it’s brick grave.
      However, I had a friend once who had frequent brick bread for NO APPARENT REASON. Sometimes her bread would rise beautifully, sometimes not at all. I grilled her with every question I could think of for what the difference might be, but she was using the same exact ingredients, in the same exact recipe, in the same exact house and temperature, and one day it would rise, the next not. And when it didn’t rise, it didn’t rise AT ALL. I could only guess her house was haunted, and I hope this is not the case for you! Probably you just need some extra gluten. ;)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s